Modular Smartphones: Can You Still Build Your Own Phone?

The modular smartphone dream — a phone where you snap in a better camera, upgrade the processor, or replace the battery as easily as changing a case — has not materialized as originally envisioned. Google's Project Ara was cancelled. LG's modular G5 flopped. But the core ideas of modularity and repairability are experiencing a revival in different forms.

What Happened to Project Ara

Google's Project Ara envisioned a phone skeleton that accepted hot-swappable modules — camera, speaker, battery, screen. Users could customize their phone and upgrade individual components. The project was cancelled in 2016 because the engineering challenges were immense. The connectors between modules added thickness, reduced performance, and created reliability issues. The market research also showed most consumers did not want to assemble their phones.

Fairphone: The Spiritual Successor

Fairphone is the closest thing to a modular phone available today. The Fairphone 5 is designed for easy repair and component replacement. The battery, screen, camera modules, USB-C port, speaker, and earpiece are all user-replaceable with a standard screwdriver. Fairphone sells replacement parts directly and provides repair tutorials.

The modularity is not hot-swappable customization — you cannot snap in a telephoto camera or add more RAM. But you can replace worn or broken components yourself, extending the phone's useful life significantly. Fairphone commits to 8 years of software updates, matching or exceeding any competitor.

Fairphone also prioritizes ethical sourcing — fair-trade gold, conflict-free minerals, and recycled materials. The phone is competitive with mid-range Android devices in performance, though not with flagships.

Framework: Modular Laptops

While modular phones struggled, Framework Computer succeeded with modular laptops. The Framework Laptop has user-replaceable everything — RAM, SSD, battery, screen, keyboard, ports, and even the mainboard. When a new processor generation launches, you buy a new mainboard and keep everything else.

This proves the modular concept works when the form factor allows it. Laptops have more internal space for connectors and less pressure for thinness. Phones, being pocket-sized devices, have much less room for modularity engineering.

Right to Repair Movement

The modular phone concept has evolved into the broader right-to-repair movement. Legislation in the EU and several US states now requires manufacturers to provide repair manuals, sell replacement parts, and design products for repairability.

Apple launched its Self Service Repair program, selling genuine parts and tools for iPhone and Mac repairs. Samsung and Google offer similar programs. While not truly modular, these programs make component-level repair accessible to consumers for the first time.

MagSafe and Accessory Ecosystems

Apple's MagSafe and similar magnetic attachment systems represent a limited form of modularity. Snap on a battery pack, wallet, mount, or wireless charger. The phone itself is not modular, but the accessory ecosystem provides some of the customization that modular phones promised.

The Realistic Future

Fully modular phones with hot-swappable components are unlikely to arrive. The engineering tradeoffs — thickness, weight, performance, water resistance — are too significant. But phones designed for repairability with user-replaceable batteries, screens, and ports are becoming the norm thanks to legislation and consumer demand.

The modular phone dream did not die — it evolved. Instead of customizing your phone's capabilities with snap-in modules, you extend its lifespan by replacing worn components. That is less exciting but more practical.

---

As an Amazon Associate, BestElectronicsReviewed earns from qualifying purchases.