HEAD-TO-HEAD COMPARISON
Epson ES-580W vs Brother ADS-1700W
We compare the Epson ES-580W and Brother ADS-1700W head-to-head on performance, features, value, and more. Here's which one wins.
Our Pick
Check Price on AmazonEpson ES-580W
Scored 9.3/10 in our testing
Best Value
Epson ES-580W
Best value wireless document scanner with large touchscreen
Overall:9.3/10Winner
Check price on Amazon Best Compact
Brother ADS-1700W
Best compact scanner for small desks and receipts
Overall:8.9/10
Check price on Amazon Score Breakdown
| Epson ES-580W | Category | Brother ADS-1700W |
|---|---|---|
| 9.3/10 ✓ | Performance | 8.8/10 |
| 9.4/10 ✓ | Features | 8.5/10 |
| 9/10 | Ease of Use | ✓ 9.4/10 |
| 9.3/10 ✓ | Value | 9/10 |
| 9.3/10 ✓ | Overall | 8.9/10 |
Specs Comparison
| Epson ES-580W | Spec | Brother ADS-1700W |
|---|---|---|
| 35 pages per minute | Speed | 25 pages per minute |
| 100-sheet ADF | Feeder | 20-sheet ADF |
| Yes | Duplex | Compact — fits in desk drawer |
| 4.3-inch touchscreen | Display | Wi-Fi + USB |
| Wi-Fi + USB + Ethernet | Connectivity | 2.8-inch touchscreen |
Epson ES-580W
Pros
- + 100-sheet ADF — double the competition
- + Lower price than ScanSnap
- + Ethernet for shared scanning
- + Good bundled software
Cons
- − Slightly slower at 35 ppm
- − Bulkier than ScanSnap
- − OCR not quite as accurate
Brother ADS-1700W
Pros
- + Ultra-compact — fits in a drawer
- + Great for receipts and small batches
- + Wi-Fi for wireless scanning
- + 2.8-inch touchscreen
Cons
- − Slower at 25 ppm
- − Small 20-sheet feeder
- − Not ideal for large batch jobs
Our Verdict
Based on our scoring, the Epson ES-580W comes out on top with an overall score of 9.3/10. The Epson ES-580W matches the ScanSnap's touchscreen experience at a lower price, and its 100-sheet feeder is double the capacity. Ethernet connectivity is a bonus for shared office environments.
Buy the Epson ES-580W on AmazonRead the full Best Document Scanners 2026 guide for complete reviews of all 3 products.