Question 1

Which is better, Plunge All-In Cold Plunge or Ice Barrel 400?

Accepted Answer

Both products scored 8.5/10 in our testing — it's a tie. Choose based on which features matter most to you.

Question 2

Is the Plunge All-In Cold Plunge worth it over the Ice Barrel 400?

Accepted Answer

The Plunge All-In Cold Plunge scores 8.5/10 while the Ice Barrel 400 scores 8.5/10. The Plunge All-In Cold Plunge is our "Best Overall" pick in the Best Cold Plunge Tubs 2026 category.

Plunge All-In Cold Plunge vs Ice Barrel 400: Which to Buy?